DUI attorneys occasionally assume responsibiltty for a case whereby someone had forced an impaired person to drive. That person may then attempt to raise the defense of duress.
This defense is generally available where there is evidence that the defendant committed the crime involuntarily because of circumstances which constituted a real, imminent, and impending danger to the defendant or a loved one. Occasionally, someone forces an impaired person to drive. That person may then attempt to raise the defense of duress.This defense is generally available where there is evidence that the defendant committed the crime involuntarily because of circumstances which constituted a real, imminent, and impending danger to the defendant or a loved one. Fort Lauderdale DUI attorneys argue that the defense is available where the evidence shows that the defendant believed and had reasonable grounds to believe that the danger was real, imminent, and impending and committed the crime for that reason.The Florida Supreme Court has approved one standard jury instruction for both duress and necessity.
The Defense of Duress in Florida is Tricky Claims Broward County DUI Lawyer William Moore:
As with entrapment, there are no Florida cases directly on point, so Fort Lauderdale DUI attorneys rely on Morrison v. State supports the availability of such a defense in a DUI case. In Morrison, the defendant was accused of driving the get-away car in a robbery. In that case, there was evidence that the co-defendant threatened physical harm to the defendant if she did not drive. There was also evidence that the co-defendant continued to curse and direct her while she was driving and that the defendant was hysterical and crying. The court ruled that the trial judge erred in denying an instruction on duress.Fort Lauderdale DUI attorneys also argue that courts of other states have considered the availability of a duress defense. In People v. Pena, the court approved the defense where the defendant claimed that he drove because a deputy took the defendant's girlfriend away under peculiar circumstances that caused him to fear for her safety. In State v. Fogarty, the court rejected the defense because, while officers ordered the defendant to leave the scene of a disturbance, they did not order him to get drunk or drive drunk. These officers did not know the defendant was intoxicated and the defendant did not tell them. Furthermore, fear of a lawful arrest cannot be the foundation for a duress defense. Finally, in State v. Riedl, the court rejected the defense claim that a duress instruction was appropriate because the defendant feared that some men at a bar would harm him. The court pointed out that the defendant drove for about five miles and there was no showing that the threatening men were continually in pursuit.
Related Articles & Posts
- Can I argue self defense if charged with posession of a firearm by a convicted felon?
- Necessity Defenses
- Using the Insanity Defense
- Criminal Defense & Right to a Speedy Trial
- THE TACTICAL DECISION TO RESERVE OPENING BY A DUI DEFENSE ATTORNEY AT TRIAL
- Self Defense
- The Burden of Proof Explained by Palm Beach Criminal Defense Attorney
- Attempted DUI
- Knowledge is Power Basic Concepts For Criminal Defense
- The Mosquito Defense
Criminal Defense Hotline: (954) 523-5333
Speak to a veteran 20 year career criminal lawyer from our Law Firm right here in Broward County.
Any Day/Any Hour, No Waiting, No Consultation Fee
Additional crime topics
- DUI Defense
- Finding the "Best DUI Lawyer in Broward County"
- DUI in Florida
- Florida DUI Law
- What are the penalties for a DUI conviction?
- DUI Practice & Procedure
- Where are Florida DUI Checkpoints?
- Florida DUI Facts
- Defending DUI is Complex
- Repeat DUI
- Self-Representation - Public Defenders
- Challenging Breath Test Results
- Our Broward County DUI Defense Book
- Crime of Fraud
- Disorderly Conduct
- Criminal Mischief
- Shoplifting Lawyers
- Common Criminal Charges
- Grand Theft Auto
- Assault and Battery
- Domestic Battery
- Juvenile Delinquency
- Court Hearings & Motions
- Pre-Trial Motions & Criminal Trial
- Pre-Trial Motions Criminal Law Question & Answer by our Fort Lauderdale Lawyers
- After the Arrest
- Setting a Bond Hearing
- Miranda Rights
- The Officer Didn't Read Me My Rights
- How is a Motion to Suppress Used by the Defense?
- Identification Evidence
- Voice Identification
- Fingerprint Evidence
- Double Jeopardy
- Jurisdiction Limitations of Police Officers
- Plea Agreements in Florida
- Plea Deals
- Violation of Probation